Masters Theses
Abstract
"Two of the most frequent applications of operations research in open pit mining are those for definition of final pit limits and production schedules. While numerous packages are available for the ultimate pit limit definition, only two competing packages are available for production scheduling: Whittle Programming’s Four-X and the Earthworks Corporation’s NPVScheduler.
Using a statistically designed experiment, a series of ultimate and optimal pits were generated for a selected deposit using each of the evaluated packages with the optimization criterion in the evaluations being both the cash flow and the net present value. Benchmarking NPVScheduler against the industry standard Whittle Four-X, the resultant optimal and ultimate pit shells were evaluated and compared for accuracy, optimality and technical practicality.
The ultimate pits generated by both software packages were essentially the same in value, size and shape. Through the process of “high grading,” the optimal pits generated by NPVScheduler tended to be smaller in size but similar in value to those generated by Whittle Four-X"-- Abstract, p. iii
Advisor(s)
Golosinski, Tad S.
Committee Member(s)
Wilson, John W.
Kohser, Ronald A.
Department(s)
Mining Engineering
Degree Name
M.S. in Mining Engineering
Publisher
University of Missouri--Rolla
Publication Date
Spring 1999
Pagination
xvii, 97 pages, CD-ROM
Note about bibliography
Includes bibliographical references (pages 92-96)
Rights
© 1999 Terrey Alan Bush, All rights reserved.
Document Type
Thesis - Restricted Access
File Type
text
Language
English
Thesis Number
T 7579
Print OCLC #
41625721
Recommended Citation
Bush, Terry Alan, "A comparison of open pit design and scheduling techniques" (1999). Masters Theses. 4398.
https://scholarsmine.mst.edu/masters_theses/4398
Geology - Plan.pdf (12913 kB)
Whittle Worst Case Results.pdf (11508 kB)
Experiment 1 - Summary.pdf (260 kB)
Experiment 2 - Summary.pdf (352 kB)
Experiment 3 - Summary.pdf (260 kB)
Experiment 4 - Summary.pdf (249 kB)
Experiment 5 - Summary.pdf (248 kB)
Experiment 6 - Summary.pdf (265 kB)
Experiment 7 - Summary.pdf (266 kB)
Experiment 1 - Summary.pdf (15 kB)
Experiment 2 - Summary.pdf (6 kB)
Experiment 3 - Summary.pdf (16 kB)
Experiment 4 - Summary.pdf (15 kB)
Experiment 5 - Summary.pdf (15 kB)
Experiment 6 - Summary.pdf (12 kB)
Experiment 7 - Summary.pdf (14 kB)
11w.pdf (39 kB)
12w.pdf (39 kB)
13w.pdf (39 kB)
14w.pdf (39 kB)
15w.pdf (39 kB)
21w.pdf (36 kB)
22w.pdf (36 kB)
23w.pdf (36 kB)
24w.pdf (36 kB)
25w.pdf (36 kB)
31w.pdf (39 kB)
32w.pdf (39 kB)
33w.pdf (39 kB)
34w.pdf (39 kB)
35w.pdf (39 kB)
41w.pdf (37 kB)
42w.pdf (38 kB)
43w.pdf (37 kB)
44w.pdf (37 kB)
45w.pdf (36 kB)
51w.pdf (37 kB)
52w.pdf (37 kB)
53w.pdf (37 kB)
54w.pdf (36 kB)
55w.pdf (36 kB)
61w.pdf (39 kB)
62w.pdf (39 kB)
63w.pdf (39 kB)
64w.pdf (40 kB)
65w.pdf (40 kB)
71w.pdf (39 kB)
72w.pdf (39 kB)
73w.pdf (39 kB)
74w.pdf (39 kB)
75w.pdf (39 kB)
Whittle Best Case Results.pdf (11828 kB)
Experiment 1 - Summary.pdf (271 kB)
Experiment 2 - Summary.pdf (315 kB)
Experiment 3 - Summary.pdf (270 kB)
Experiment 4 - Summary.pdf (260 kB)
Experiment 5 - Summary.pdf (257 kB)
Experiment 6 - Summary.pdf (331 kB)
Experiment 7 - Summary.pdf (285 kB)
Experiment 1 - Summary.pdf (15 kB)
Experiment 2 - Summary.pdf (12 kB)
Experiment 3 - Summary.pdf (16 kB)
Experiment 4 - Summary.pdf (15 kB)
Experiment 5 - Summary.pdf (15 kB)
Experiment 6 - Summary.pdf (12 kB)
Experiment 7 - Summary.pdf (12 kB)
11b.pdf (38 kB)
12b.pdf (38 kB)
13b.pdf (39 kB)
14b.pdf (39 kB)
15b.pdf (39 kB)
21b.pdf (36 kB)
22b.pdf (36 kB)
23b.pdf (35 kB)
24b.pdf (35 kB)
25b.pdf (35 kB)
31b.pdf (39 kB)
32b.pdf (39 kB)
33b.pdf (39 kB)
34b.pdf (39 kB)
35b.pdf (39 kB)
41b.pdf (37 kB)
42b.pdf (38 kB)
43b.pdf (37 kB)
44b.pdf (36 kB)
45b.pdf (36 kB)
51b.pdf (37 kB)
52b.pdf (37 kB)
53b.pdf (36 kB)
54b.pdf (36 kB)
55b.pdf (36 kB)
61b.pdf (39 kB)
62b.pdf (39 kB)
63b.pdf (39 kB)
64b.pdf (39 kB)
65b.pdf (39 kB)
71b.pdf (39 kB)
72b.pdf (39 kB)
73b.pdf (39 kB)
74b.pdf (39 kB)
75b.pdf (39 kB)
NPVScheduler Results.pdf (12075 kB)
Experiment 1 - Summary.pdf (324 kB)
Experiment 2 - Summary.pdf (314 kB)
Experiment 3 - Summary.pdf (323 kB)
Experiment 4 - Summary.pdf (321 kB)
Experiment 5 - Summary.pdf (309 kB)
Experiment 6 - Summary.pdf (333 kB)
Experiment 7 - Summary.pdf (323 kB)
Experiment 1 - Summary.pdf (14 kB)
Experiment 2 - Summary.pdf (12 kB)
Experiment 3 - Summary.pdf (16 kB)
Experiment 4 - Summary.pdf (15 kB)
Experiment 5 - Summary.pdf (15 kB)
Experiment 6 - Summary.pdf (13 kB)
Experiment 7 - Summary.pdf (16 kB)
11.pdf (33 kB)
12.pdf (32 kB)
13.pdf (32 kB)
14.pdf (32 kB)
15.pdf (32 kB)
21.pdf (27 kB)
22.pdf (28 kB)
23.pdf (29 kB)
24.pdf (30 kB)
25.pdf (29 kB)
31.pdf (33 kB)
32.pdf (33 kB)
33.pdf (32 kB)
34.pdf (32 kB)
35.pdf (33 kB)
41.pdf (29 kB)
42.pdf (30 kB)
43.pdf (31 kB)
44.pdf (32 kB)
45.pdf (31 kB)
51.pdf (27 kB)
52.pdf (29 kB)
53.pdf (30 kB)
54.pdf (31 kB)
55.pdf (30 kB)
61.pdf (33 kB)
62.pdf (33 kB)
63.pdf (33 kB)
64.pdf (33 kB)
65.pdf (33 kB)
71.pdf (33 kB)
72.pdf (33 kB)
73.pdf (33 kB)
74.pdf (33 kB)
75.pdf (33 kB)
Case 1 Data Comparison.pdf (44 kB)
Case 1 - Section.pdf (10474 kB)
Case 1 - Plan.pdf (5033 kB)
Case 2 Data Comparison.pdf (46 kB)
Case 2 - Section.pdf (16094 kB)
Case 2 - Plan.pdf (12603 kB)
Case 3 Data Comparison.pdf (47 kB)
Case 3 - Section.pdf (16525 kB)
Case 3 - Plan.pdf (13098 kB)
Figure 4.3 and Figure 4.4.pdf (323 kB)
Figure 4.5.pdf (138 kB)
Figure 4.6 and Figure 4.7.pdf (216 kB)
Figure 4.8 and Figure 4.9.pdf (153 kB)
Figure 5.1 - Figure 5.14.pdf (184 kB)
Figure 6.1 and 6.2.pdf (323 kB)
Figure 6.3 and 6.4.pdf (329 kB)
Figure 6.5 and 6.6.pdf (236 kB)
Figure 6.7 and 6.8.pdf (235 kB)
Figure 6.9 and 6.10.pdf (248 kB)
Figure 6.11 - Figure 6.19.pdf (63 kB)
Figure 6.20 and Figure 6.21.pdf (361 kB)
Figure 6.22 and Figure 6.23.pdf (344 kB)
Figure 6.24 and Figure 6.25.pdf (327 kB)
Figure 6.26 and Figure 6.27.pdf (246 kB)
Figure 6.28 and Figure 6.29.pdf (254 kB)
Figure 6.30 and Figure 6.31.pdf (255 kB)
Figure 6.32 and Figure 6.33.pdf (249 kB)
Figure 6.34 and Figure 6.35.pdf (240 kB)
Figure 6.36 - Figure 6.44.pdf (80 kB)
Figure 6.45 and Figure 6.46.pdf (372 kB)
Figure 6.47 and Figure 6.48.pdf (353 kB)
Figure 6.49 and Figure 6.50.pdf (340 kB)
Figure 6.51 and Figure 6.52.pdf (252 kB)
Figure 6.53 and Figure 6.54.pdf (260 kB)
Figure 6.55 and Figure 6.56.pdf (264 kB)
Figure 6.57 and Figure 6.58.pdf (251 kB)
Figure 6.59 and Figure 6.60.pdf (244 kB)
Figure 6.61 and Figure 6.62.pdf (238 kB)
Figure 6.63 - Figure 6.71.pdf (90 kB)
Share My Thesis If you are the author of this work and would like to grant permission to make it openly accessible to all, please click the button above.
Comments
Accompanying CD-ROM, available at Missouri S&T Library, contains a number of tables and figures referred to in the text.