Artificial Virtue: The Machine Question and Perceptions of Moral Character in Artificial Moral Agents
Virtue ethics seems to be a promising moral theory for understanding and interpreting the development and behavior of artificial moral agents. Virtuous artificial agents would blur traditional distinctions between different sorts of moral machines and could make a claim to membership in the moral community. Accordingly, we investigate the “machine question” by studying whether virtue or vice can be attributed to artificial intelligence; that is, are people willing to judge machines as possessing moral character? An experiment describes situations where either human or AI agents engage in virtuous or vicious behavior and experiment participants then judge their level of virtue or vice. The scenarios represent different virtue ethics domains of truth, justice, fear, wealth, and honor. Quantitative and qualitative analyses show that moral attributions are weakened for AIs compared to humans, and the reasoning and explanations for the attributions are varied and more complex. On “relational” views of membership in the moral community, virtuous machines would indeed be included, even if they are indeed weakened. Hence, while our moral relationships with artificial agents may be of the same types, they may yet remain substantively different than our relationships to human beings.
Gamez, P., Shank, D. B., Arnold, C., & North, M. (2020). Artificial Virtue: The Machine Question and Perceptions of Moral Character in Artificial Moral Agents. AI and Society Springer.
The definitive version is available at https://doi.org/10.1007/s00146-020-00977-1
Arts, Languages, and Philosophy
Center for Science, Technology, and Society
International Standard Serial Number (ISSN)
Article - Journal
© 2020 Springer, All rights reserved.
25 April 2020